This is not a review, and I don't hand out stars either. It is part of my annotated reading list. Whatever first comes to mind when I pick up the book. More about it in this blog post. The English text is a translation made with an LLM, which I check and revise myself.
written on November 19, 2026, first read 2003
After writing the rather heavyweight piece on Max Frisch’s “Montauk”, I’d like to write about a completely different book today. In my article on how I got my fear of flying under control, I wrote about two books I bought. One was Henry Mintzberg’s “Why I Hate Flying”. I’ve already written about that book, and I give it at least some of the credit for the fact that I eventually got on a plane again. The other book was “Endlich fliegen ohne Angst!” (“Finally Flying Without Fear!”) by Allen Carr.
It was a resounding success. Not. At. All. And that wasn’t even really the book’s fault. It looked quite promising. Everything was reassuring. It explained a lot. I can imagine that this really works for some people. It felt as if you were lying down on a soft sofa and someone were speaking to you in a calm voice: “You don’t need to be afraid. It’s really not that bad. And for every objection you have, I’ll explain to you why you needn’t worry.” A rather fluffy approach, I’d say.
It addressed the most common fears. Carr wrote that planes don’t crash because of turbulence, don’t collide in mid-air and don’t lose their wings in mid-flight. And all of it sounded well thought out. And right.
Well, the problem with the book was what had happened before I read it. On 12 November 2001 a plane crashed over Queens because the controls were mishandled in wake turbulence. Through his control inputs in the turbulence, the pilot flying had overstressed the aircraft to such an extent that the vertical stabiliser broke off.1 Around the time I was reading the book, more and more reports were emerging that turbulence had indeed been one of the triggers. Over Lake Constance in Germany, two planes collided on 1 July 2002, and in the US a firefighting aircraft lost both wings in flight on 17 June 2002. Gulp.
If he had written that planes don’t fly into buildings, I’d probably still be taking the train today. Sorry about that, but I remember that thought exactly. Reality had reduced a large part of the argument to absurdity.
The book sits on my shelf; I haven’t read it in ages. It’s only still there so that I have proof that I’m not joking when I tell the story of my fear of flying, and of why two books worked in exactly the opposite direction to the one their titles indicated.
Whether books like “Endlich fliegen ohne Angst!” can work depends heavily, I think, on how the fear came about. What probably matters is whether you know too much or too little about it. And if you know too much, whether you see it all in the right context. Carr’s approach probably works considerably better for a fear born of ignorance, because it tackles the ignorance.
But if you already know a lot – and can actually put it into rational perspective – and still don’t get on the plane, the only things that help are either to let it be or to find something in return that makes it worth looking the fear in the eye.
That’s why Mintzberg’s book worked for me (although that isn’t the book’s aim at all) and Carr’s didn’t.
Perhaps this book also explains my aversion to self-help literature. Such books can give very generic tips at best. That’s in the nature of things. An author wants to sell lots of books, after all, and the target group “person with an almost cartoonish fear of flying who is nevertheless interested in aviation” is probably not big enough to merit a book of its own.
I don’t want my fears argued away, my worries put into perspective. At least not when it’s plain to see that they aren’t unfounded. On top of that, as an author you run the risk of life catching up with your own work. As with the three examples I mentioned. If I read the book again today, with 23 years’ distance, I’d probably find a good many more points.
You don’t have to fly without fear, as the title suggests. That goal is too big. In my view it’s completely illusory once you’ve piled up so much fear that you didn’t board. It’s enough if you’re left with only so much fear that you can fly again. Or if you have your fear under control to the point where travelling by plane is possible again.2
Fears are something very personal, something very specific. Perhaps it’s a little presumptuous to think you only have to go to a bookshop to rid yourself of them, and perhaps it’s also a little presumptuous to believe you only have to write a book about it.
I think the same goes for grief, addictions, longings, but also for all the bad habits you pick up over a lifetime. And yet there are shelves full of these books.
What it really takes is a personal self-help book. I’ve tried several times to explain how I got my fear of flying under control. In that blog article, but also to acquaintances who had the same problem. Ultimately, I can’t. It was my way, a way, not the way. And I know it won’t work for most people. That’s why there’s only a rather autobiographical blog article about it and no book in the shops. My way out of the fear of flying can only be understood together with the life story around it and, where it fits, transferred to someone’s own fear of flying.
In my article on “Riding Rockets” by Mike Mullane I voiced my unease about self-help literature: my idea of writing a book that advocates eating an apple every year at Easter may really make some people feel fortified, health-wise, for the year ahead. Most people’s stomachs will turn at the thought of eating a piece of fruit before their first coffee.
So perhaps such books should be called “How I Lost 30 Kilos” or “How I Managed to Get Back on a Plane” rather than making the promise of salvation of “Endlich fliegen ohne Angst!”. I think role models work better here than fluffy explanations.
In the English original, the book is called “The Easy Way to Enjoy Flying”. Nothing about this way is easy, because it means confronting your own most basic fears, first and foremost the fear of death. I don’t want to say that Carr’s book doesn’t work at all. I can imagine that it will work for many people. Especially if all they need is a little nudge. It’s a way. It’s their way. But it wasn’t my way.
PS: Among other things, Carr wrote a book that’s meant to help you quit smoking. I hope it works better than his book on fear of flying.
