Quicksearch
Navigation
Events
Trusted Ad
Blower Door Test
Luftdichtigkeitsmessung für Gebäude Raum Hamburg ab 160 excl. MwSt
www.m-tectum.de
Luftdichtigkeitsmessung für Gebäude Raum Hamburg ab 160 excl. MwSt
www.m-tectum.de
Kategorien
About this blog- Apple
- iPhone
- Aviation
- Bahn
- Begriffe des Lebens
- Blogosphere
- Braindump
- Business Travel
- CANBOX
- CeBIT
- CEC
- Computing
- del.icio.us
- Fundsache
- General
- i hate sundays
- Kochen
- Mindfuck
- Movies
- Music
- On Benchmarketing
- Persoenliches Pech
- Photographie
- policy of ...
- Privacy
- Recommended Blogs
- Security
- Solaris
- Strange Days
- Sun
- suncec2007
- suncec2008
- Technology
- The IT Business
- Toolbox
- Travel
- Work
Benchmarketing again - this time: TPC-H 10 TB
Thursday, November 29. 2007
Wow, itīs benchmarketing time at IBM again. IBM Announces DB2 and POWER6 Combo Trounces HP and Sun by 2x and 3x Respectively in New Business Intelligence Benchmark. IBM you are soooo great .... you was able to beat our TPC-H 10 TB by a factor of 3. Itīs really an technological archievement in 2007 to beat a TPC-H benchmark result generated on on 29th November 2005 ... exactly 2 years ago today. Come on ... in IT 2 years are a fscking long time ....
Everytime i read a benchmark from IBM, i really looking forward to read their disclosure to see, what you can do in benchmarking, when you have nearly unlimited resources.
The configuration of IBM consists out of: 32 p6 p570 servers, each server had 32 GB of memory, resulting in 1 TB memory. Each of the systems had 96 36 Gigabyte 15k harddisks with 4 GB/s FC. A whooping amount of 3072 harddisks. A fully 10 GB enabled network.
The SF25K result was done on 1296 disk, with 10k rounds with 2 GB/s. The memory had a size of 288 GB. On a single system with a single operating system image The system used the old UltraSPARC with 1.5 GHz
Not that you canīt buy an system from Sun equivalent system from IBM. The venerable SF25k now has up to 1.15 TB per domain. And the M9000 class servers are a completly different story. But,dear IBM,when you want to make a statement of relative performance, the system should be at least somewhat similar.
So dear IBM, next time you want to showcase you system, donīt do it against a benchmark 2 years old. Whatīs the statement of such a press announcement: We are 3 times faster with our top of the line system with a benchmarking configuration than a 2 years old configuration. Big deal, IBM, really big deal ...
Everytime i read a benchmark from IBM, i really looking forward to read their disclosure to see, what you can do in benchmarking, when you have nearly unlimited resources.
The configuration of IBM consists out of: 32 p6 p570 servers, each server had 32 GB of memory, resulting in 1 TB memory. Each of the systems had 96 36 Gigabyte 15k harddisks with 4 GB/s FC. A whooping amount of 3072 harddisks. A fully 10 GB enabled network.
The SF25K result was done on 1296 disk, with 10k rounds with 2 GB/s. The memory had a size of 288 GB. On a single system with a single operating system image The system used the old UltraSPARC with 1.5 GHz
Not that you canīt buy an system from Sun equivalent system from IBM. The venerable SF25k now has up to 1.15 TB per domain. And the M9000 class servers are a completly different story. But,dear IBM,when you want to make a statement of relative performance, the system should be at least somewhat similar.
So dear IBM, next time you want to showcase you system, donīt do it against a benchmark 2 years old. Whatīs the statement of such a press announcement: We are 3 times faster with our top of the line system with a benchmarking configuration than a 2 years old configuration. Big deal, IBM, really big deal ...
Posted by Joerg Moellenkamp
in Sun
at
18:01
| Comments (6)
| Trackback (1)
View as PDF: This entry | This month | Full blog
View as PDF: This entry | This month | Full blog
Comments
Display comments as
(Linear | Threaded)
Das ist wie bei Versicherungen: Wer liest schon das Kleingedruckte? 
Not to mention that the ibm systems is bound to be several times more expensive than the sun system.
Oldest trick in the book - compare your current server to an old product of your competitors - or in this case, IBM compares 32 of their newest machines to only 1 2 year old machine from Sun. They must not be able to do the single system performance or compete against Sun's recent boxes.
I agree: This trick is so old, itīs hard to believe they still use it. But: The untold story ist the more interesting part in benchmarking. And using 32 systems instead of 8 is the most interesting part.
IBMs Marketing and $$$ can outperform everything in marketing live. When you spend 1 Billion on Marketing you can sell shit as pudding. It is still: never has onyone been fired because of buying IBM: hey guys it's time you get fired!!!! Be sure: opensource and Sun will give you all a hell of a fire, relaxing time is gone.
Just my 2 cents.
PS: Yes we have Sunsystems and these boxes work fine, and also yes: I bought Sunshares.
Just my 2 cents.
PS: Yes we have Sunsystems and these boxes work fine, and also yes: I bought Sunshares.
Hmm, i think "nobody getīs fired for buying ibm" is not correct anymore. Itīs more like "Nobody gets fired for x in a x shop". Nobody gets fired for buying IBM in an IBM shop (even itīs nonsensical, i had such a customer in the past, wo wanted to migrate to Linux on IBM Blades, come hell or high water) as well nobody gets fired for buying Sun in a Sun shop.
The LKSF book
The book with the consolidated Less known Solaris Tutorials is available for download here
Web 2.0
Contact
Networking
open.bc
LinkedIn
Facebook
My photos
- mail: joerg@c0t0d0s0.org
- icq: 144000169
- Me, myself and I
- openBC
- My del.icio.us
- c0t0d0s0@twitter
- c0t0d0s0@last.fm
- wiki@c0t0d0s0
- Amazon Wishlist
Networking
open.bc
My photos
Syndication
Comments
about INTJ
Thu, 04.12.2008 23:55
"Detected language German. The only supported languages are English and Swedish. But stay tuned, we are expanding. [...]
Thu, 04.12.2008 23:55
"Detected language German. The only supported languages are English and Swedish. But stay tuned, we are expanding. [...]
about Leaked Airbus "787 lessons learned" presentation
Thu, 04.12.2008 22:09
Funny .. i guess another lesso ns learnt case would be: Do not circulate too much confid ential information among [...]
Thu, 04.12.2008 22:09
Funny .. i guess another lesso ns learnt case would be: Do not circulate too much confid ential information among [...]
about Overpopulated
Thu, 04.12.2008 17:36
Oh yeah, try being on a dual q uad core and running MenuMeter s, just the CPUs alone take up a lot of space. Can [...]
Thu, 04.12.2008 17:36
Oh yeah, try being on a dual q uad core and running MenuMeter s, just the CPUs alone take up a lot of space. Can [...]
about Deutschsprachiger Anwenderbericht zu Opensolaris 2008.11
Thu, 04.12.2008 15:41
Jo ... einige Dinge sind nicht ganz korrekt ... aber im gros sen und ganzen finde ich den T ext gut
Thu, 04.12.2008 15:41
Jo ... einige Dinge sind nicht ganz korrekt ... aber im gros sen und ganzen finde ich den T ext gut
about Deutschsprachiger Anwenderbericht zu Opensolaris 2008.11
Thu, 04.12.2008 15:17
"Ab Version 2008.11 kann man a uch von ZFS booten." na das ging aber auch schon mit 2008 .05...
Thu, 04.12.2008 15:17
"Ab Version 2008.11 kann man a uch von ZFS booten." na das ging aber auch schon mit 2008 .05...
Getaggte Artikel
AMD Apple avs Bahn Blogging Blogosphere braindump Business Travel CeBIT cec cec2006 CMT del.icio.us deutsch dtrace fliegen Fundsache General Hamburg IBM i hate sundays Intel iscsi jumpstart Links Linux lksf Mindfuck Movies Music Musik Niagara Opensolaris Opteron Photographie policy of ... Politik Security Solaris storage Sun suncec2007 sunw t1 The IT Business Ultrasparc ultrasparc t1 Wirtschaft Work ZFS
Blog Administration
Buttons
I thought a little bit about the TPC-H benchmark published by IBM yesterday. There is something in it, that leaves some question. The p570 is a 8 socket system. You can build it by stacking 4 two-socket boxes with some special cabling. Thatīs one of the p
Tracked: Nov 30, 09:39